FDA expands access to Plan B for 17-year-olds
Agency will allow drug to be sold over the counter to minors
WASHINGTON - The Food and Drug Administration says it will allow 17-year-olds to get the ‘morning-after’ birth control pill without a doctor’s prescription.
The FDA said Wednesday it will not appeal a federal judge’s order overturning restrictions that were imposed during the Bush administration.
U.S. District Judge Edward Korman ruled that Bush administration appointees let politics, not science, drive their decision to allow over-the-counter access only for women 18 and older.
Korman ordered the FDA to let 17-year-olds get the medication. He also is ordering the agency to evaluate whether all age restrictions should be lifted.
In a statement, the FDA indicates that it is ready to approve the change once the manufacturer requests it.
Plan B is emergency contraception that contains a high dose of birth control drugs and will not interfere with an established pregnancy. Religious conservatives say it’s the equivalent of an abortion pill because it can prevent a fertilized egg from attaching to the uterus.
The battle over access to Plan B has dragged on for the better part of a decade, through the tenure of three FDA commissioners. Among many in the medical community, it came to symbolize the decline of science at the agency. Top FDA managers refused to go along with the recommendations of scientific staff and outside advisers that the drug be made available over-the-counter with no age restrictions.
“The FDA got caught up in a saga, it got caught up in a drama,” said Susan Wood, who served as the agency’s top women’s health official and resigned in 2005 over delays in issuing a decision. “This issue served as a clear example of the agency being taken off track, and it highlighted the problems FDA was facing in many other areas.”
Conservatives said the FDA should have appealed the judge’s ruling.
“This decision is driven by politics, not what is good for patients or minors,” said Wendy Wright, president of Concerned Women for America, a public policy group representing religious conservatives. “Parents should be furious at the FDA’s complete disregard of parental rights and the safety of minors.”
If taken within 72 hours of unprotected sex, Plan B can reduce a woman’s chances of pregnancy by as much as 89 percent.
It contains a high dose of birth control drugs and works by preventing ovulation or fertilization. It also may prevent a fertilized egg from implanting into the uterus, but recent research suggests that’s not likely. In medical terms, pregnancy begins when a fertilized egg attaches itself to the wall of the uterus.
The treatment consists of two pills and sells for about $35 to $60. Women must ask for Plan B at the pharmacy counter, and show identification with their date of birth. The drug is made by a subsidiary of Teva Pharmaceutical Industries, an Israeli company. It does not prevent sexually transmitted infections, such as HIV/AIDS.
Supporters of broader access argued that Plan B was safe and effective in preventing unwanted pregnancy, and could also help reduce the number of abortions.
Opponents, including prominent conservatives, countered that it would encourage promiscuity, and might even become a tool for criminals running prostitution rings, as well as for sexual predators.
Early in the Bush administration, more than 60 organizations petitioned the FDA to allow sales without a prescription. But according to court documents, the issue quickly became politicized.
In 2003, a panel of outside advisers voted 23 to 4 to recommend over-the-counter sales without age restrictions. But top FDA officials told their subordinates that no approval could be issued at the time, and the decision would be made at a higher level. That’s considered highly unusual, since the FDA usually has the last word on drug decisions.
In his ruling, Judge Korman said that FDA staffers were told the White House had been involved in the decision on Plan B. The government said in court papers that politics played no role.
In 2005, the Center for Reproductive Rights and other organizations sued in federal court to force an FDA decision.
The following year, the FDA allowed Plan B to be sold without a prescription to adults. But the controversy raged on over access for teens.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/30350234
Crocs
~~~~~~~~~PUBLIC POST~~~~~~~~~
1I just heard this.
2More government erosion of parental rights.
===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
17 is the age of consent in some states so I don't see why this is an issue. However, I think they should consider that, if the age of consent differs from state to state then maybe the age to be able to get a Plan B pill should coincide with the age of consent?
3that would make sense kim.
also, I know that the main thing i worried about when i was a teen was getting pregnant and not diseases, i hope these girls will still use protection.
~~~~~
The man who speaks to you of sacrifice, speaks of slaves and masters. And intends to be the master.
4Eh... Maybe it's just my mood, but honestly, this country is going to sh*t, so, what's next?
5
6When 13 year olds hide the fact that she got knocked up by her 16 year old boyfriend and then delivers in her bathrooms and tosses the baby down the garbage chute or in the alley (from a 5 story window) - this is a better option. 17 year olds are not minors like we were growing up. I think today's teens are way more ahead of the curve then we were. These kids are to young & stupid to breed.
I also don't see why who manufactures it matters.
7***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Sam - You make a good point.
This really bothers me: "Korman ordered the FDA to let 17-year-olds get the medication. He also is ordering the agency to evaluate whether all age restrictions should be lifted."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
8Stop Fiscal Slavery
there has to be a cut off point but as long as kids practice unsafe sex and get knocked up at 13, 14, 15 years of age and are too afraid tell their parents I am not sure what you can do unless you want to support another generation or two on welfare.
9***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Sam, I'm mean. I'm all for making them carry to term and give it up for adoption.
10I think going through that experience would be educational.
===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
except that most would not be adoptable by those who want a child and further burden the over crowded foster care system which you & I pay for. And the worst part is they go and do it again in a year or two. I think we should create one of those simulators for pregnancy and put them all through it. That should curb their urges until well into their twenties.
11***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
A simulator sounds great!
12Complete with 30 pounds of belly weight, pressure on you bladder, and random abdominal thumping at 2 am.
===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
I don't know. Laura's comments makes a lot of sense to me. What the H***. Maybe it's just my old fashion nature but my disgust factor is on mega overload.
13can we add in babies crying at all the time and that stinky smell that can come from something so small and yet level a platoon.
14***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Ah, yes, a combination of curdled milk and poop. Def have to include that.
15===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
At this rate we will definitely have a decrease in the US population. baby poop - eeeeeewwwwwww!
16***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
at least the latest in diapers no longer require safety pins.
17and these are all the reasons why I will never have a kid!
~~~~~
The man who speaks to you of sacrifice, speaks of slaves and masters. And intends to be the master.
18brook, who can blame you. love 'em but its the responsibility that never ends!
19Brook, I'm 100% with you. If I wasn't sure already, spending time with my baby nephew totally confirmed it!
I love him to death, but he poops. (Also, I don't cope well with life when I don't have enough sleep.) (Also, the actual giving birth part freaks me out enough to
keep me from getting pregnant) (I can go on all day, seriously)
20chaton - oh me too! i think the birth is what initially scares me the most! eeks! and yeah, i'm a real crabby pants without sleep.
pam - they are adorable, but i don't think i could handle it. i'd be the strictest parent ever. i think i'd make an awful mom! some people are just cut out to be moms and they are awesome...me, not so much. hehe
~~~~~
The man who speaks to you of sacrifice, speaks of slaves and masters. And intends to be the master.
21The morning after pill is just a large dose of birth control pills, so what is the age of consent for getting the Pill?
22they have to be prescribed by a doctor so probably as young as a doctor is willing to write a script for.
23***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
That brings up another question: Does a 16- or 17-y-o have to have parental consent for the Pill? If so, why is it not required for a larger dosage or the same stuff?
24===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
i don't know. I have heard of parents bringing their daughters in to get them on the pill as young as 12-13 years old. I don't know if a girl went in on her own would they write it? If they go to a clinic they might fill the script there at to charge, so no parent needed.
25***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
I think parental consent is required for medical attention for a minor.
Think of the cases we've seen of Christian Scientists refusing treatment for terminal illnesses for their children.
I'm a big fan of consistency.
26===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
Having both adopted and fostered, let me assure you a normal healthy infant has absolutely no problem being adopted. The waiting list of eligible couples is so long, many agencies no longer do case studies for couples unless they are willing to adopt older, or "special needs" children. Why do you think so many couples adopt from around the world, despite the horrific costs?
27the ones i know - because they did not want what was being offered in foster care
28***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Parental consent is definitely not always required for minors to receive medical care, particularly in cases of reproductive health. I can say with 100% certainty that there are states in our country (in fact, it may be all states) in which minors can receive a prescription for birth control pills without parental consent. In fact, it goes even further in that it is illegal to inform the parents without the minor's permission in many cases.
29What is offered in foster care, are either older or "special needs". A baby, released by a mother never even sees the inside of a foster home. The only babies that do, are addicted, or otherwise neglected. The agency works with the parent, to make it safe to put the child back with the mother, if that fails, and the mother won't release that child, the agency goes into court to sever parental rights, and puts the baby up for adoption. The whole process can take up to 4 years. Unless those babies have disabilities, they too are quickly adopted.
30That putting back with crack addicted mommy has not worked all that well here. A lot of the babies are brokered privately. The gay couples have been adopting a lot of special need or older kids. i know you fostered kids GP and lean towards it. I have seen the end result of those unwanted pregnancies - preventing conception is much better. No being should know in its first hours on this planet fear, cold and pain. That is not G-d's plans, that is man's inhumanity.
31***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Thanks for the info, lilkim!
32===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
Sam, preventing pregnancy is absolutely the ideal. Unfortunately the TV shows, and movies never seem to talk about the problems, and dangers of premarital sex, just that is "normal;", and "everyone does it". Too many young teens are not mature enough, or sensible enough to fully understand the unintended consequences not only with regards to pregnancy, but also the plethora of STD's out there.
33we really need a better health/sex education system
34***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
When you consider how hard it is to come forward after a rape and face the examination, further humiliation, intimate photos taken by strangers, all the while knowing that processing rape kit DNA is backlogged almost 2-3 years in some states PLUS our history as a nation of failing to find and actually put the offender in prison...and on the other hand knowing you can just go get Plan B and then go see a therapist and your personal physician---what would you do?
Now I know that is NOT the typical reason that Plan B is used but from my volunteer work with abused women, many wished they had gone that route. It sickens me that so many rapists never get caught. I know that reporting it is the right thing to do BUT when they are caught they rarely get more than 3 years...the victim gets life. I totally get it that many victims would choose Plan B and then move on with their life.
Now consider date rape, that one time you got sh*t-faced in college and woke up in a unfamiliar place with no memory of what happened and then worried for a month until you knew if you were pregnant or not, and that one really bad spur of the moment hot night with someone you immediately regretted...and Plan B sounds like it would have saved you a lot of misery.
My 16 year old is on the pill. As soon as she started dating seriously I took her down and got her the pill because when you do grown-up things, you need to be responsible. My mother didn't do that for me. After a rape at 14 with three weeks of torment not knowing if another innocent was now in the picture---I was not going to let that happen to my kid. If you have never been there, at age 14, you cannot look at this in a perspective that has any connection to reality.
I don't care how old you are-- if you NEED Plan B --you should not have to beg for it-- you should not have to justify the need to anyone -- nor should any self-righteous narrow-minded person be able to determine whether or not you can have Plan B.
Each person has to live with their own conscience ultimately. Nobody else.
BTW...I see at least 6 girls/women EVERY WEEK that is faced with a family member or friend that assaulted them...and they won't press charges. Plan B saves them. That is reality people. Those are the faces we see everyday, neighbors, friends, roommates, sisters, best friends, mothers, daughters and yes...even grandmothers.
35Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.