* PUBLIC POST *
Excerpts only, as it is a somewhat long article. This captures the spirit; the full text contains more examples and background.
MSNBC’s Sexist Hypocrisy: Open Season on Conservative Women
In America, only liberal women enjoy protection from public degradation and disgusting characterizations.
By Jeff Poor and Colleen Raezler
Culture and Media Institute
April 15, 2009
On February 7, 2008, MSNBC’s David Shuster claimed Chelsea Clinton was being “pimped out” by her mother Hillary Clinton’s, presidential campaign.
Retribution quickly followed. News broke the very next day that Shuster’s comments had earned him a two-week suspension. The National Organization for Women (NOW) quickly issued a statement that called on NBC to “skip the sexism and report the news.” And while NOW praised NBC for its “swift and decisive action” against Shuster, the group also pointed out “a pattern at MSNBC: insult, apology, insult, apology.”
Yet, just over a year later, the network and NOW are hewing to a very different standard when it comes to women on the right. MSNBC personalities refer to a Republican congresswoman as a “Mata Hari,” and call a former female Republican vice-presidential nominee a “mail order bride” and characterize her as a dragon and a dog, and there’s no apology and no outrage.
For conservative women, it appears the strategy at MSNBC is “insult, insult, insult.”
...
Since the fall of last year, “Hardball” host Chris Matthews has made it a mission to hone in on Bachmann, one of 435 members of the U.S. House of Representatives, beginning with an aggressive line of questioning when she called some liberalism, including that coming from Obama associates William Ayers and Rev. Jeremiah Wright, “anti-American.”
On his March 27 show, he questioned her desire to protect the United States dollar and referred to her as “the Mata Hari of Minnesota” for her efforts in the House to statutorily defend the U.S. Dollar.
“It’s not clear why she did it since nobody on the planet, least of all here in America is talking about switching to some new multinational currency here,” Matthews said.
...
The liberal media’s disdain for conservative women has a long and varied history, from Florida’s Katharine Harris, who was called “Cruella De Vil,” to the hated Ann Coulter to the “blond and witchy” Elisabeth Hasselbeck.
But no woman has drawn liberal ire like former GOP vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin, and nobody has attacked Palin with the vitriol of MSNBC.
Starting with its coverage of the Republican National Convention in August, Matthews and several of the other on-air NBC News talent that appeared on MSNBC’s special coverage – including former “Nightly News” host Tom Brokaw and NBC correspondents Chuck Todd and Andrea Mitchell -- immediately keyed in on the pro-life candidate’s stance on abortion.
...
After Palin spoke out against the character assassination the media carried out against her, Olbermann joked on January 13, 2009, “What’s the difference between a governor of Alaska and a pitbull? You can train a pitbull to occasionally keep its mouth closed.”
As for NOW, they issued no statements on the treatment Palin and Bachmann received from MSNBC during the 2008 general election cycle except to say of Palin, that her nomination was “a cynical effort to appeal to disappointed Hillary Clinton voters and get them to vote, ultimately, against their own self-interest.”
...
Colleen Holmes, executive director of the conservative Eagle Forum told CMI, “Michelle Malkin summarized it perfectly when she noted that the liberals have a tendency to infantilize, sexualize, demonize and dehumanize conservative women. It’s astounding how intolerant liberals are of jokes about liberal women, and yet they’ll say, or at least tolerate the most bawdy, degrading and patronizing things about conservative women.”
Full article at: http://www.cultureandmediainstitute.org/articles/2009/20090415134622.asp...
Pinko
Some how this just makes me very sad.
sexist hypocricy brought to you by the party of tolerance.
1No!!!!! Tell me it is not true. You mean the MSM is biased, and womens rights only aply to college educated liberal women.
2Yeah, lucky for Hillary Clinton, Michelle Obama and Nancy Pelosi that no one ever targets liberal women.
3Yeah, lucky for Hillary Clinton, Michelle Obama and Nancy Pelosi that no one ever targets liberal women.
4Yeah, because Michelle Obama got the same treatment that Sarah Palin received this last election.
5Steph, you are not going to tell me that it is not safe to attack any female who is not a, college graduate liberal female? The women sexually harassed by Bill Clinton is probably the most egregious example. Compare the reaction of N.O.W to the plethora of women who accused bill Clinton, to the reaction of N.O.W to one individual woman accusing Clarence Thomas.
6I also give you the attacks on Sarah Palin's family, her mode of dress, and her accent.
7Any woman in the spotlight is a target, but only liberal women get apologies and defended by NOW.
8They don't give a sh*t. I have no faith. It will never change. NOTHING will ever change!!!
Blahblahblahblah
9Deep breathe Laura. The liberal MSM will continue to use name calling due to the lack of facts and gray matter. And liberal women are stupid enough to except it, unless of course it happens to them and then they get like Janeane Garofalo.
10***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Isn't it just like someone to stop by and roll her eyes at us, and then never come back?
Heck, there are even whole groups of people whose sole mission is to find out whether or not Sarah Palin's baby was actually the baby of one of her daughters. Would this happen to a liberal woman? Oh no, she'd be applauded for being the mother who does it all.
11Ninja posters: All attitude; less substance.
12===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
so does that make them the paris hiltons and lindsay lohans of sugar?
13***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
only way less photogenic
14***************
"Ever tried, ever failed, no matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail Better." - Samuel Beckett
Sam: Paris Hilton + Lindsay Lohan - good looks = Perez Hilton
Yup, sounds about right.
15===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
The story is probably posted on sugar but I had to throw in the Miss America pageant as an example of sexist hypocrisy.
The gorgeous & amazingly poised Miss California just got her come up-pins because she dared to answer the question posed to her about marriage, honestly from her heart. By doing so, she was openly humiliated & called dumb b****.
In other words, young women who do not subscribed to liberal ideology are no longer welcome to compete in the Miss America pageant. Outrageous!
16Michelle Obama? As a target of the media?
She's the MSM's little darling. Check out any
newsstand & you'll see her face on the cover of just about every magazine talking about how fabulous she is.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
17Stop Fiscal Slavery
Yeah, because Michelle Obama got the same treatment that Sarah Palin received this last election
If you are going to compare Sarah Palin* to someone from the 2008 elections that is a woman, at least say Hillary Clinton. And then at least admit that Hillary Clinton had mud slinging at her from both sides of the spectrum.
And if you are going to compare Michelle Obama to someone one, at least make it comparable to another spouse like Cindy McCain.
The reaching is insurmontable!
*And also if you were to take off the rose-colored sunglasses, you might be able to see that Sarah Palin was a walking contradiction, what with her abstinence-only agenda AND pregnant unwed-teenage daughter at home...that's begging for a media-crap storm.
18"*And also if you were to take off the rose-colored sunglasses, you might be able to see that Sarah Palin was a walking contradiction, what with her abstinence-only agenda AND pregnant unwed-teenage daughter at home...that's begging for a media-crap storm."
All I can do as a parent is try to instill values in my children. If those values don't stick, how on earth does it impugn my values? We were just "celebrating" the 10th anniversary of the slaughter of children in a high school by two other seriously disturbed children. Does that means the parents of the two killers are walking contradictions for following and preaching the 10 commandments, respect for human life, and respect for the law?
19"And if you are going to compare Michelle Obama to someone one, at least make it comparable to another spouse like Cindy McCain."
Because the media was so kind and generous with Cindy McCain.
Also, Cindy was not *nearly* as visible during the campaign as Michelle.
The "slinging" at Hillary was almost all part of the actual debate, not personal criticism of her family or her wardrobe. When the economic woes started, did anyone point out that Chelsea worked/s for a hedge fund?
20===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
"The "slinging" at Hillary was almost all part of the actual debate, not personal criticism of her family or her wardrobe."
Try again--I've read TONS of comments mocking everything from her "cackle" of a laugh to (well, obviously) her husband to her love of pantsuits. Gimme a break.
21And I agree with tia--if you're gonna compare Michelle to anyone, yeah, make it Cindy. Both have gotten pretty rough attacks--even now, people on this site say "Wow, Michelle looks like @ss". Yeah, that's productive!
22"Colleen Holmes, executive director of the conservative Eagle Forum told CMI, “Michelle Malkin summarized it perfectly when she noted that the liberals have a tendency to infantilize, sexualize, demonize and dehumanize conservative women. It’s astounding how intolerant liberals are of jokes about liberal women, and yet they’ll say, or at least tolerate the most bawdy, degrading and patronizing things about conservative women.” "
I also still hold that Michelle Malkin is an awful example of what a conservative woman believes. She's kind of like Ann Coulter minus the ability to market herself.
23Excuse me, what a conservative woman *is*.
24"Try again--I've read TONS of comments mocking everything from her "cackle" of a laugh to (well, obviously) her husband to her love of pantsuits. Gimme a break"
Em, when Bill Clinton was elected, Hillary took the stance that she was also elected. Her own presumptuous stance created a lot of the criticism.
As for Maulkin, your comment confuses me em:
"I also still hold that Michelle Malkin is an awful example of what a conservative woman believes."
An "awful example" ? by your standards? are you a conservative woman?
25"Try again--I've read TONS of comments mocking everything from her "cackle" of a laugh to (well, obviously) her husband to her love of pantsuits. Gimme a break."
I haven't seen an extraordinary number of personal criticisms of Hillary.
Maybe I just don't read / view the same stuff you do.
Michelle vs. Cindy:
I haven't seen the piece-by-piece breakdown with (inflated) price estimates of any of Michelle's outfits that we saw with Cindy. Also, Cindy did not take a central role like Michelle did.
"I also still hold that Michelle Malkin is an awful example of what a conservative woman believes. She's kind of like Ann Coulter minus the ability to market herself."
26...thus proving the point.
I may think that Rachel Maddow looks like a half-shaved pit bull and Anderson Cooper is an effeminate silver-spoon brat, but I don't make a point of saying so. It does not contribute to civil discourse.
===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
I find it interesting that on a thread about Liberal women insulting Conservative women, we have a Conservative woman calling Liberal women stupid.
27Which to ME, doesn't contribute to civil discourse.
28Just trying to frame your characterization of Malkin in comparable terms on the liberal side. And making the point that I sometimes have views that are as uncharitable as others I've read here...but I don't feel the need to air them.
Again, commenters' vague insults of conservative media women just serves to prove the original writer's point.
Whoosh....
BTW, I did not call anyone stupid.
29===================================
Conservative in exile
Washington and Sacramento: Stealing our children's futures.
I never said you did, Lain.
30This is REALLY REALLY funny. It's so interesting how quickly people forget. Hillary had just as many personal attacks as Palin. Jeeze. I know because I won top talker on Citizen defending her from BOTH sides of the spectrum.
31I mean, I think Michelle Malkin is a moron. She b!tched about Rachael Ray wearing a scarf that resembled something a "terrorist" would wear. And while I'm not a conservative, some of my friends are, and they're not morons. Aaaaand I'm entitled to my opinon of her--whether or not you think I should express it is neither here nor there.
She's mentioned in the article, not Maddow or Cooper. So I think my comments about her are
a bit more relevant in this thread than whatever you think about any liberal commentator.
"Em, when Bill Clinton was elected, Hillary took the stance that she was also elected. Her own presumptuous stance created a lot of the criticism."
Funny, I didn't see "Clinton/Clinton/Gore" campaign signs when I was a little kid.
32And just because you don't feel the need to air them doesn't mean I don't. I don't agree with a lot of liberal commentators--big deal, who cares? I also don't feel the need to put someone pointing a gun to someone else's head as my avatar, but again, neither here nor there!
33And if you care about Malkin's viewpoint from the liberal side, most of the level-headed liberals I know also think she's a moron. But hey, kudos to Townhall for employing her.
34Em, honestly just not sure what that means -- the "level-headed liberals" - please expand on that.
35I guess level headed means their heads don't come to a point, or maybe tilt oddly.
36
I'll be on the lookout for a level headed one. As yet, none in sight.
37Grandpa, btw, your comment made me think of the SNL characters & movie, the coneheads.
38from France
39that's right! they were from France. figures!
40Post A Comment
To post comments, please log in or register.